| Rev. John Francis R. Chambon 1860 – 1867 | ||
| Rev. H. M. Delafosse 1867 – 1868 | ||
![]() | Rev. Henry Peter Clavreul, V.G. Ordained March 19, 1859 1868 – 1872 | |
| Rev. Stephen Allen Langlade Ordained 1871 1872 – 1875 | ||
| Rev. J. P. Fanny 1875 – 1877 | ||
![]() | Rev. Henry Peter Clavreul, V.G. Responsible for the construction of today's Historic Church | |
![]() | Rev. James J. Veal, D.D. 1902 – 1909 | |
| Rev. Thomas J. Nolan 1909 – 1911 | ||
| Rev. John Karsseleers 1911 – 1913 | ||
| Rev. Stephen J. Brown 1914 – 1915 | ||
| Rev. M. Greham 1916 | ||
| Rev. William Nachtrab 1916 – 1921 | ||
![]() | Rev. Michael Fennell 1921 – 1930 | |
| Rev. Hugh Farrelly 1932 – 1935 | ||
| Rev. George Terence Rockett 1936 – 1942 | ||
![]() | Rev. Thomas Joseph McDonough (later Auxiliary Bishop of St. Augustine, Bishop of Savannah, then Archbishop of Louisville) 1942 – 1943 | |
![]() | Rev. Patrick Joseph Bresnahan 1943 – 1946 | |
| Rev. William J. O'Farrell Ordained June 13, 1931 1946 – 1949 | ||
| Rev. R. T. Rastatter 1949 | ||
| Rev. Bernard T. Smith 1949 – 1951 | ||
| Rev. Robert W. Schiefen 1951 – 1952 | ||
| Rev. John P. Burns 1952 – 1958 | ||
![]() | Rev. Joseph Lynn Dawson Ordained May 19, 1951 1958 – 1965 | |
| Rev. Joseph Corde Ordained June 29, 1925 1965 – 1969 | ||
![]() | Rev. Joseph Lynn Dawson Ordained May 19, 1951 1969 – 1972 | |
| Rev. Thomas Francis Kelly Ordained June 12, 1960 1972 – 1982 | ||
![]() | Rev. Daniel Cody Ordained June 1962 1982 – 2013 | |
![]() | Most Rev. Thanh Thai Nguyen (Bishop in the Diocese of Orange in Southern California) Ordained May 11, 1991 2013 – 2017 | |
![]() | Rev. Sebastian K. George, CMI Ordained March 23, 1980 2017 – 2023 | |
![]() | Rev. David Ruchinski Ordained June 23, 2007 2023 - PRESENT |